Are You Looking For An Advertising Boom
One important reason to obtain a patent is for advertising purposes. Once a patent is applied for you can immediately use the coveted term patent pending in your advertising. If a patent issues you can also advertise try my patented X, where represents whatever it is that you patented. The public at large knows very little about patent law, but most recognize that to get a patent means something special . If you are looking for this kind of reward from the fruits of your patent labors, then trying for a recipe patent could be well worth your time and money, particularly if you are a restaurant owner. Even if you dont necessarily think you have a good chance to ultimately get a patent filing that patent application so you can say: try our patent pending world famous Maragritas!
Warning & Disclaimer: The pages, articles and comments on IPWatchdog.com do not constitute legal advice, nor do they create any attorney-client relationship. The articles published express the personal opinion and views of the author as of the time of publication and should not be attributed to the authors employer, clients or the sponsors of IPWatchdog.com. Read more.
How Can I Protect My Food Recipe As Intellectual Property
Everybody loves food, except maybe the United States Patent and Trademark Office. Restaurateurs and chefs have a notoriously hard time trying to patent their recipes, and most patent filings dont result in securing successful legal protections.
Of course, the USPTO doesnt actually hate food rather, recipes simply dont fall under the definition of a patent, copyright, or trademark. However, there are still ways to safeguard your intellectual property outside of getting USPTO or Copyright protections. Lets demystify the patent protections process and learn how to keep your recipes safe.
Your Food Invention Should Be Novel
According to Section 2 of the Indian Patent Act, invention means a new product or process involving an inventive step, and capable of industrial application.
If you have come up with a process or food composition, make sure its new or novel. If nobody has done it before, It passes novelty test.
Since the basis of applying for a patent is that you have developed a new recipe, this criteria should be easy to meet.
Don’t Miss: Healthy Zucchini Recipes For Weight Loss
Is The Recipe Useful
Most applicants have no trouble with this requirement because all foods are helpful.
So, its pretty easy to demonstrate the importance of a food recipe.
However, this should not be a leeway to not taking this qualification seriously.
However, obvious as its benefits may seem, its still essential to state them in the application process.
We advise that you begin with the windfalls unique to your recipe to enhance your chances of approval.
Hire A Patent Attorney To Patent Your Recipe
If you have a recipe thats new, qualifies for a patent, and you know you can commercialize, you should hire a patent attorney to protect your recipe with a patent. Preparing and filing a patent application is not an easy task, especially if you dont have experience preparing patent applications.
That said, its unheard of to hear about an inventor who has prepared, filed, and patented his own invention, its not an easy task. Making even seemingly minor mistakes could get your patent application rejected, requiring you to spend time and money fixing the mistake.
The USPTO even allows inventors to prepare and file their patent application on their own, they will even assist you with it. However, they do recommend that you hire a patent attorney or patent agent to assist you in preparing, filing, and communicating with the patent office.
If you dont have the money to hire a patent attorney, you can hire a patent agent. Patent agents are qualified and licensed to prepare, file, and communicate on your behalf with the patent office. For more information on patent agents, click here. They could save you a ton of money while getting your recipe the same type of patent protection an attorney would.
Recommended Reading: High Protein Breakfast Recipes For Weight Loss Vegetarian
What Is A Trademark
A trademark is a word, phrase, and/or design that refers to a specific product or service. Trademark is often used as an umbrella term, but it specifically refers to products, while service mark refers to services.
With a trademark, youre not protecting the process or invention. Youre protecting the brand around that process or invention. Additionally, trademarks never expire as long as they remain in use. This can be an effective way to protect your creations.
Can You Patent A Food Idea
This is a question weve recently been receiving quite oftenis it possible to patent a food idea?
To answer it, we should have some basic understanding of how the U.S Patent Laws work.
The United States Patent and Trademark Office is the body in charge of granting or revoking patent rights in the U.S.
It protects unique inventions, processes, machines, and designs from sale, reproduction, dissemination, and use without the inventors consent.
Among the Patent Laws guiding USPTO in performing its roles is that any work submitted for patenting must be fixed to a tangible medium.
In simple terms, applicants must present physical evidence of their inventions.
For instance, if you want to patent a song, you must attach its written down lyrics or audio/video recording.
Therefore, it is not possible to patent a food idea.
An idea is abstract and does not have any patentable subject matter.
Instead, you must first convert it into a recipe and attach it to a tangible medium.
The recipe must contain either a unique composition of ingredients or a new food-making process.
Some people prefer not to patent their recipes because the process requires full disclosure.
To register a recipe for patenting, you must state all of its ingredients and clearly describe the process of mixing them to come up with the final product.
With all the recipes components and processes divulged, its pretty easy for somebody else to steal the food idea before you complete the registration.
Don’t Miss: Dog Treat Recipes No Pumpkin
What Kind Of Recipes Can Be Patented
One way to overcome an obviousness rejection and persuade a skeptical Patent Examiner is to demonstrate that there are certain aspects of an invention that are counter-intuitive. If you really have something that is counter-intuitive then it becomes a little disingenuous to argue that it would have been common sense to do this or that to result in the invention. So if you are going to try and patent a recipe ask yourself are there any process steps that are unique, even bizarre? Things that are counter-intuitive or contra-indicated can go a long way toward helping establish a patentable invention, as do solutions to vexing problems.
Here are a couple recipe related patents to give you an idea of what you might be able to protect:
Fat and egg yolk substitute Fats and eggs produce desirable taste and sensory qualities in the baked goods, but also contribute much fat and cholesterol to the baked items. This substitute is a particular composition that is claimed to produce a desirable taste and provide desirable sensory qualities. This recipe, therefore, provides a solution to a particular problem. Notice the very specific ratios of ingredients.
You can also always protect software and data management systems, including those that relate to recipes, such as U.S. Patent No.7,523,302, which relates to an electronic recipe management system, or U.S. Patent No. 6,975,910, which relates to managing an electronic cookbook.
How The Uspto Defines A Food Recipe
Before explaining the different types of intellectual property protections , its important to understand how the USPTO views and defines a recipe. After understanding this definition, we can match up a recipe against each type of IPP.
Generally, the USPTO defines something based on its basic components. So, the USPTO breaks a recipe down into 3 things: the ingredients themselves, the processes these ingredients undergo, and the resulting dish in relation to these ingredients.
You May Like: Liquid Diet Bariatric Surgery Recipes
How To Get A Patent Or Trademark
The patent process can get complicated, so youll probably want to hire a patent attorney. They will do a thorough search of the current patent databases to make sure that your invention or design is unique enough to qualify for a patent.
A design patent will require a title, description, and explanation of how your design is unique. Youll need drawings of your design as well. The design patent application process will probably cost a few thousand dollars, between fees and legal expenses.
Trademarks are much easier to get than patents. You can fill out the paperwork online without an attorney if you wish. Youll have to prove that the mark is either in use or going to be used, which typically means youre selling something under the name.
Youll also have to identify the industry that the mark will apply to. Chef Steves trademark of Cannolio® is specifically related to cookies and pastries. If someone else sold or marketed a car called the Cannolio®, theyd be perfectly allowed to do that!
What Types Of Foods Have Earned Food Patents
The USPTO has awarded patents to countless types of food and recipes over the past two centuries. Most of them are involve improvements to processes and products.
For example, the inventor who extended the shelf life of foods with additives gained a patent. The innovations of mass cheese production and mass cereal production also earned patents. Anything that makes foods last longer or the manufacturing process easier is worthy of a food patent.
Some other examples of food patents include:
The basic rules of patents still apply to all the categories above. A person must prove utility and newness. You also must apply to patent the idea within a year of thinking of it.
What’s a Good Way to Apply for a Food Patent?
The best approach is to think about food in the way that the USPTO will. Since Patent Class 426 evaluates claims in terms of composition of matter or the process for making the product, you should as well.
This patent application isn’t like writing a recipe. General guidelines like using an iron skillet and stirring every 10 minutes aren’t useful. You need to describe your food or recipe at the molecular level. You’re now describing the physical composition of the ingredients. It’s a much easier way to prove newness and originality. You can use science to support the claim.
You also need to prevent competitors from stealing your idea after it’s patented. While you should add specifics for the process, describe the cooking steps as broadly as possible.
Also Check: Hot Toddy With Whiskey Recipe
Opting To Protect A Food Recipe As A Trade Secret
Many creators of famous food recipes have opted to protect their creations by protecting them as trade secrets. Protecting a food recipe as a trade secret allows the creator of a recipe to avoid having to disclose all of the ingredients and process that goes into creating a food item. So, if youre thinking about patenting a food idea that you have, ask them about trade secret protection and see what they have to say.
Companies such as Coca Cola have protected their secret formulas for beverages by protecting them as trade secrets instead of patenting them because they dont want to disclose to the public how to make their product. Patents only last for 20 years, so had Coca Cola patented its formula decades ago, people would now be able to make the popular drink thats consumed by billions of people on a daily basis around the world.
Is The Recipe Non
Non-obvious here means that a random person in the recipes field should not consider it obvious.
In simple terms, the recipe should not be a product of common sense.
For example, lets say you came up with a recipe for making a salad that lasts for five days without wilting the salad.
A regular salad maker should not be able to create the exact product without following your recipe.
Read Also: Quick And Easy Baked Zucchini Recipes
How Do You Stop Others From Copying Your Delicious Recipe
All your friends agree: You make the best chicken noodle soup that they have ever tasted. Perhaps, you think, you could profit from your innovative recipe. You begin to consider marketing your soup and selling it to local restaurants, or even to grocery stores in cans. But is “your” recipe for the soup really protectable? Or can someone else simply copy “your” recipe and make his or her own soup?
Whether or not you own exclusive intellectual property on the recipe depends on whether you qualify for one of the four legal areas of intellectual property protection: copyright, trademark, patent, or trade secret. While some limited protections may apply, food recipes are actually rather difficult to protect. Let’s analyze each of the four primary categories:
Copyright. Copyright protection gives creators of literary and artistic works certain exclusive rights. As the U.S. Copyright Office explains, individual recipes are difficult to protect because no matter how delicious the results, they often lack the necessary literary expression. . A collection of recipes, as in a cookbook, can be protected. That protection is stronger if the author adds original literary commentary and uses creativity in the selection of recipes. Merely listing ingredients, however, is likely not enough.
Can I Copyright My Food Recipe
What a patent doesnt protect, a copyright might. Right? Copyrights protect the authorship of a creative work. This makes it impossible to reproduce all or part of a certain, distinct element in a creative publication, whether thats a novel, poem, painting, or song such as the McDonalds Big Mac recipe song!
To the chagrin of many chefs and restaurant owners, copyright very rarely applies to recipes. Although there is a creative art to making great food, this art isnt protectable in what a recipe outlines. Recipes simply outline ingredients and processes, so what the recipe publishes isnt considered to be the novel, inventive production of artits simply a list of steps. There are two exceptions to this. First, you can copyright a recipe if the finished product is intended to be an art piece. If the food is also modern art, and the foods production is intended for artistic consumption , then that food may be eligible for copyright protections. However, it is the foods design that is being copyrighted, not the recipe itself.
Second, you can copyright a cookbook or a collection of recipes. Because this is considered a creative content publication, cookbooks are eligible for copyright protections. You can even trademark a series of cookbooks or blogs about food, provided these publications carry a distinct weight to your brand.
Read Also: New York Times Vegetarian Recipes
Determine If You Need To Hire A Patent Agent
You must hire a patent agent if:
- the application is filed by someone other than the inventor
- there is more than 1 inventor and the application is not filed jointly by all of the inventors
- a transfer of the application had been recorded with the office
Why you should hire an agent even if you aren’t required to
Preparing and filing a patent application is not easy and can be time consuming. Think about hiring a licensed patent agent to help you. Patent agents understand patent and intellectual property laws and the application process.
Make sure your patent agent is licensed.
You can help your agent get the strongest possible patent while avoiding unnecessary costs by preparing a statement that includes the following information about your invention:
Can You Patent Your Recipe In India
Under the current laws of the country, you can patent your recipe, more specifically both the dish and its process.
This has become possible after the major amendment of 2005 in the Indian Patent Act. This amendment extended product patents for food, pharma, and chemical inventions.
It was Section 5 of the Indian Patent Act 1970 that prohibited product patents for food, pharma, and chemical inventions. It was entitled Inventions where only methods or processes of manufacture patentable.
The good news is that Section 5 was omitted by the amendment of 2005.
It has been observed that most of the claims of food-related patents consist of process and composition claims. Moreover, process claims have more chances of patent grant than composition-based claims.
This should not deter you from pursuing composition claims for your recipe. In this regard, you should keep in mind that only process claims were allowed before 2005.
You may be wondering what is a process claim for a food item. It's the preparation steps that are undertaken while preparing your food item. The steps of preparing a food item may include heating, frying, freezing, mixing, stirring, grinding, fermenting, baking, brewing, etc. One or more of these steps form the process of preparing the food item. Let's look at what is a recipe? a recipe is a set of instructions to prepare a food item including a list of ingredients required.
Read Also: Keto Meatloaf Recipe Pork Rinds
Work With An Attorney To File Your Paperwork
Filing patent paperwork can feel like an overwhelming task. However, there are many patent lawyers who specialize in filling out all of the required paperwork required by the USPTO. Although youre allowed to complete and submit that paperwork on your own, the USPTO recommends that you hire an attorney to manage the paperwork and make certain that you submit all the materials required. These papers are submitted to the patent office electronically regardless of whether you file them or have a patent attorney do it for you. The patent application itself should be filed either via regular mail or online .